| Page 139 | Kisaco Research
 

Emmanuel Gougé

Honourable Judge
UPC Court of Appeal

Emmanuel Gougé

Honourable Judge
UPC Court of Appeal

Emmanuel Gougé

Honourable Judge
UPC Court of Appeal
 

Emmanuel Gougé

Judge
UPC Court of Appeal

Emmanuel Gougé

Judge
UPC Court of Appeal

Emmanuel Gougé

Judge
UPC Court of Appeal

This session examines how the UPC’s evolving case law on equivalence compares with national practices in jurisdictions such as the UK, Germany, and Brazil. With recent UPC decisions applying the four-prong test to life sciences disputes, panellists will assess whether the doctrine is delivering legal certainty while ensuring fair protection for patentees.

• Analyse how recent UPC rulings apply the doctrine of equivalents and compare with approaches in the UK, Germany, and Brazil.
• Are the four key UPC questions workable in practice, especially in the life sciences context?
• Evaluate the balance between legal certainty for third parties and fair protection for patent holders under the UPC system.

Author:

Viviane Kunisawa

Partner
Daniel Law

Viviane Kunisawa

Partner
Daniel Law

Author:

Liz Cohen

Partner
Bristows

Liz Cohen

Partner
Bristows

Author:

Julia Schönbohm

Partner
Linklaters

Julia Schönbohm

Partner
Linklaters

Author:

Jon Singer

Principal
Fish & Richardson

Jon is a principal in the firm’s San Diego office and heads the life sciences litigation practice. He appears regularly as lead counsel in his matters and handles all aspects of litigation, including leading jury and bench trials, trying cases to administrative and arbitration panels and conducting briefing and arguments before the U.S. Courts of Appeals and the PTAB. Jon is annually named one of the nation’s finest life sciences trial attorneys and is an expert in proceedings under the Hatch-Waxman Act. His clients consistently praise his innovative and ground-breaking work and over the past two decades, he has successfully handled dozens of cases covering all aspects of the life sciences.

Jon Singer

Principal
Fish & Richardson

Jon is a principal in the firm’s San Diego office and heads the life sciences litigation practice. He appears regularly as lead counsel in his matters and handles all aspects of litigation, including leading jury and bench trials, trying cases to administrative and arbitration panels and conducting briefing and arguments before the U.S. Courts of Appeals and the PTAB. Jon is annually named one of the nation’s finest life sciences trial attorneys and is an expert in proceedings under the Hatch-Waxman Act. His clients consistently praise his innovative and ground-breaking work and over the past two decades, he has successfully handled dozens of cases covering all aspects of the life sciences.

Claim Construction at the UPC: A Review of EPO, National and UPC Case Law This session examines the UPC’s evolving approach to claim interpretation, highlighting key decisions that clarify how claims are construed in comparison with EPO and national practices. It will explore recent landmark rulings and ongoing developments shaping patent litigation strategies.


• Review the UPC Court of Appeal decision NanoString Technologies v. 10xGenomics, which clarified the standard for interpreting patent claims based on Article 69 EPC and its Protocol, affecting both infringement and validity assessments.
• Examine the ongoing question of whether the file wrapper should be considered in claim construction, which awaits a final decision by the UPC Court of Appeal.
• Analyse the decision of G1/24 and its impact upon claims raised at national courts, the EPO and the UPC.

Author:

Sabine Agé

Partner
Hoyng Rokh Monegier

Sabine Agé

Partner
Hoyng Rokh Monegier

Author:

Agathe Michel-De-Cazotte

Partner
Carpmaels & Ransford

Agathe Michel-De-Cazotte

Partner
Carpmaels & Ransford

Author:

Manuel Neetz

IP Counsel
Siemens Healthineers

Manuel Neetz

IP Counsel
Siemens Healthineers
 

Aditya Agarwal

Director, Robotics
Nimble Robotics

Aditya Agarwal

Director, Robotics
Nimble Robotics

Aditya Agarwal

Director, Robotics
Nimble Robotics
 

Liz Powell

Founder & President
G2G Consulting

Liz Powell

Founder & President
G2G Consulting

Liz Powell

Founder & President
G2G Consulting
 

Valerie Palmieri

Chief Executive Officer
MOMENTUM Consulting

Valerie Palmieri

Chief Executive Officer
MOMENTUM Consulting

Valerie Palmieri

Chief Executive Officer
MOMENTUM Consulting